Round 1
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 1 | Mariano Rivera | RP | NYY | Pythagorean Triples |
| 2 | Elvis Andrus | SS | AZ | Jag Off Guards |
| 3 | Unknown | — | — | The 4 Aces |
| 4 | Brandon Allen | 1B | CIN | Amalgamated Morons |
| 5 | Dustin Ackley | 1B | NYY | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 6 | Gordon Beckham | 2B | SD | Turnbull AC's |
| 7 | Alex Avila | C | WSH | The Baseball Furies |
| 8 | Adrián Béltre | 3B | TEX | Willoughby Chubs |
| 9 | Wilson Betemit | 1B | BAL | puhd |
| 10 | Bobby Abreu | OF | NYM | Slackers |
Round 2
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 11 | Jacoby Ellsbury | OF | NYY | Pythagorean Triples |
| 12 | José Bautista | 3B | PHI | Jag Off Guards |
| 13 | Alberto Callaspo | 3B | ATL | The 4 Aces |
| 14 | Brennan Boesch | OF | CIN | Amalgamated Morons |
| 15 | J.P. Arencibia | C | TB | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 16 | Miguel Cabrera | 1B | DET | Turnbull AC's |
| 17 | Erick Aybar | SS | MIN | The Baseball Furies |
| 18 | Peter Bourjos | OF | LAA | Willoughby Chubs |
| 19 | Carl Crawford | OF | LAD | puhd |
| 20 | Mike Aviles | 2B | MIA | Slackers |
Round 3
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 21 | Johnny Giavotella | 2B | BAL | Pythagorean Triples |
| 22 | Billy Butler | 1B | ATH | Jag Off Guards |
| 23 | Alexi Casilla | 2B | BAL | The 4 Aces |
| 24 | Lorenzo Cain | OF | MIL | Amalgamated Morons |
| 25 | Coco Crisp | OF | CLE | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 26 | Chris Davis | 1B | BAL | Turnbull AC's |
| 27 | Asdrúbal Cabrera | SS | AZ | The Baseball Furies |
| 28 | Michael Brantley | OF | HOU | Willoughby Chubs |
| 29 | Nelson Cruz | OF | SD | puhd |
| 30 | Jason Donald | 2B | TEX | Slackers |
Round 4
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 31 | Adrián González | 1B | NYM | Pythagorean Triples |
| 32 | Sam Fuld | OF | ATH | Jag Off Guards |
| 33 | Shelley Duncan | 1B | TB | The 4 Aces |
| 34 | Robinson Canó | 2B | ATL | Amalgamated Morons |
| 35 | Jeff Francoeur | OF | MIA | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 36 | Rajai Davis | OF | NYM | Turnbull AC's |
| 37 | Mike Carp | 1B | BOS | The Baseball Furies |
| 38 | Johnny Damon | OF | CLE | Willoughby Chubs |
| 39 | Chone Figgins | 3B | LAD | puhd |
| 40 | Alcides Escobar | SS | WSH | Slackers |
Round 5
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 41 | Torii Hunter | OF | MIN | Pythagorean Triples |
| 42 | Adam Jones | OF | AZ | Jag Off Guards |
| 43 | Adam Dunn | 1B | CWS | The 4 Aces |
| 44 | Yunel Escobar | SS | LAA | Amalgamated Morons |
| 45 | Matt Joyce | OF | PHI | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 46 | Alejandro De Aza | OF | WSH | Turnbull AC's |
| 47 | Lonnie Chisenhall | 3B | CLE | The Baseball Furies |
| 48 | Travis Hafner | Util | NYY | Willoughby Chubs |
| 49 | Brandon Inge | 2B | PIT | puhd |
| 50 | Josh Hamilton | OF | TEX | Slackers |
Round 6
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 51 | Justin Morneau | 1B | CWS | Pythagorean Triples |
| 52 | Jason Kipnis | 2B | ATL | Jag Off Guards |
| 53 | Kosuke Fukudome | OF | NYY | The 4 Aces |
| 54 | Brett Gardner | OF | NYY | Amalgamated Morons |
| 55 | Russell Martin | C | LAD | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 56 | Tyler Flowers | C | ATL | Turnbull AC's |
| 57 | Shin-Soo Choo | OF | TEX | The Baseball Furies |
| 58 | Eric Hosmer | 1B | CHC | Willoughby Chubs |
| 59 | Brett Lawrie | 3B | CWS | puhd |
| 60 | Ian Kinsler | 2B | SD | Slackers |
Round 7
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 61 | Trevor Plouffe | 2B | PHI | Pythagorean Triples |
| 62 | Casey Kotchman | 1B | MIA | Jag Off Guards |
| 63 | Curtis Granderson | OF | MIA | The 4 Aces |
| 64 | Alex Gordon | OF | KC | Amalgamated Morons |
| 65 | Mitch Moreland | 1B | ATH | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 66 | Derek Jeter | SS | NYY | Turnbull AC's |
| 67 | Hank Conger | C | TB | The Baseball Furies |
| 68 | Maicer Izturis | 2B | TOR | Willoughby Chubs |
| 69 | Brent Lillibridge | 1B | NYY | puhd |
| 70 | Matt LaPorta | 1B | BAL | Slackers |
Round 8
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 71 | Mark Reynolds | 1B | COL | Pythagorean Triples |
| 72 | A.J. Pierzynski | C | ATL | Jag Off Guards |
| 73 | Franklin Gutiérrez | OF | LAD | The 4 Aces |
| 74 | Unknown | — | — | Amalgamated Morons |
| 75 | Ryan Raburn | 2B | WSH | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 76 | Howie Kendrick | 1B | WSH | Turnbull AC's |
| 77 | Edwin Encarnación | 1B | CWS | The Baseball Furies |
| 78 | Desmond Jennings | OF | TB | Willoughby Chubs |
| 79 | Hideki Matsui | OF | TB | puhd |
| 80 | Evan Longoria | 3B | AZ | Slackers |
Round 9
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 81 | Brian Roberts | 2B | NYY | Pythagorean Triples |
| 82 | Mark Trumbo | 1B | BAL | Jag Off Guards |
| 83 | J.J. Hardy | SS | BAL | The 4 Aces |
| 84 | Ryan Lavarnway | C | DET | Amalgamated Morons |
| 85 | Colby Rasmus | OF | BAL | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 86 | David Murphy | OF | LAA | Turnbull AC's |
| 87 | Nick Markakis | OF | ATL | The Baseball Furies |
| 88 | Kelly Johnson | 2B | ATL | Willoughby Chubs |
| 89 | Kendrys Morales | 1B | NYY | puhd |
| 90 | Mike Napoli | C | TEX | Slackers |
Round 10
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 91 | Brendan Ryan | SS | LAA | Pythagorean Triples |
| 92 | Delmon Young | OF | BAL | Jag Off Guards |
| 93 | Austin Jackson | OF | NYM | The 4 Aces |
| 94 | Adam Lind | 1B | WSH | Amalgamated Morons |
| 95 | Josh Reddick | OF | AZ | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 96 | Luke Scott | 1B | TB | Turnbull AC's |
| 97 | Victor Martínez | C | DET | The Baseball Furies |
| 98 | Paul Konerko | 1B | CWS | Willoughby Chubs |
| 99 | Brent Morel | 3B | PIT | puhd |
| 100 | Eduardo Núñez | 2B | NYM | Slackers |
Round 11
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 101 | B.J. Upton | OF | TOR | Pythagorean Triples |
| 102 | Mike Adams | RP | PHI | Jag Off Guards |
| 103 | John Jaso | C | PIT | The 4 Aces |
| 104 | Joe Mauer | C | MIN | Amalgamated Morons |
| 105 | Alex Rodriguez | 3B | NYY | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 106 | Grady Sizemore | OF | PHI | Turnbull AC's |
| 107 | Dustin Pedroia | 2B | BOS | The Baseball Furies |
| 108 | Magglio Ordonez | OF | DET | Willoughby Chubs |
| 109 | Miguel Olivo | C | LAD | puhd |
| 110 | Cliff Pennington | 2B | CIN | Slackers |
Round 12
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 111 | Matt Wieters | C | STL | Pythagorean Triples |
| 112 | Al Alburquerque | RP | CWS | Jag Off Guards |
| 113 | Tsuyoshi Nishioka | 2B | MIN | The 4 Aces |
| 114 | Mike Moustakas | 3B | CWS | Amalgamated Morons |
| 115 | Jarrod Saltalamacchia | C | DET | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 116 | Scott Sizemore | 2B | NYY | Turnbull AC's |
| 117 | Justin Smoak | 1B | MIL | The Baseball Furies |
| 118 | Jhonny Peralta | SS | STL | Willoughby Chubs |
| 119 | Alexei Ramirez | SS | SD | puhd |
| 120 | Vernon Wells | OF | NYY | Slackers |
Round 13
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 121 | Jake Arrieta | SP | CHC | Pythagorean Triples |
| 122 | Scott Baker | SP | LAD | Jag Off Guards |
| 123 | Ben Revere | OF | LAA | The 4 Aces |
| 124 | David Ortiz | 1B | BOS | Amalgamated Morons |
| 125 | Danny Valencia | 3B | BAL | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 126 | Mike Trout | OF | LAA | Turnbull AC's |
| 127 | Nick Swisher | 1B | ATL | The Baseball Furies |
| 128 | Carlos Santana | C | AZ | Willoughby Chubs |
| 129 | Alex Rios | OF | KC | puhd |
| 130 | Kevin Youkilis | 1B | NYY | Slackers |
Round 14
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 131 | Daniel Bard | SP | COL | Pythagorean Triples |
| 132 | Bartolo Colón | SP | TEX | Jag Off Guards |
| 133 | Trayvon Robinson | OF | CWS | The 4 Aces |
| 134 | Salvador Perez | C | KC | Amalgamated Morons |
| 135 | Josh Willingham | OF | KC | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 136 | Jemile Weeks | 2B | SD | Turnbull AC's |
| 137 | Eric Thames | OF | ATH | The Baseball Furies |
| 138 | Ichiro Suzuki | OF | SEA | Willoughby Chubs |
| 139 | Ryan Sweeney | OF | CHC | puhd |
| 140 | Ben Zobrist | 2B | CHC | Slackers |
Round 15
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 141 | Zack Britton | SP | NYY | Pythagorean Triples |
| 142 | Jesse Crain | RP | CWS | Jag Off Guards |
| 143 | Kurt Suzuki | C | LAA | The 4 Aces |
| 144 | Kyle Seager | 2B | SEA | Amalgamated Morons |
| 145 | Nick Blackburn | SP | MIN | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 146 | Grant Balfour | RP | TB | Turnbull AC's |
| 147 | Brett Anderson | SP | MIL | The Baseball Furies |
| 148 | Michael Young | 1B | LAD | Willoughby Chubs |
| 149 | Yorvit Torrealba | C | COL | puhd |
| 150 | Andrew Bailey | RP | LAA | Slackers |
Round 16
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 151 | Brett Cecil | SP | STL | Pythagorean Triples |
| 152 | Aaron Crow | RP | KC | Jag Off Guards |
| 153 | David Aardsma | RP | ATL | The 4 Aces |
| 154 | Mark Teixeira | 1B | NYY | Amalgamated Morons |
| 155 | Dallas Braden | SP | ATH | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 156 | Matt Capps | RP | AZ | Turnbull AC's |
| 157 | Wade Davis | SP | KC | The Baseball Furies |
| 158 | Roberto Hernandez | SP | ATL | Willoughby Chubs |
| 159 | Clay Buchholz | SP | TOR | puhd |
| 160 | Carlos Carrasco | SP | ATL | Slackers |
Round 17
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 161 | Brian Fuentes | RP | STL | Pythagorean Triples |
| 162 | Danny Duffy | SP | TEX | Jag Off Guards |
| 163 | Blake Beavan | SP | SEA | The 4 Aces |
| 164 | Henderson Alvarez | SP | PHI | Amalgamated Morons |
| 165 | A.J. Burnett | SP | PIT | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 166 | Louis Coleman | RP | DET | Turnbull AC's |
| 167 | Brandon McCarthy | SP | ATL | The Baseball Furies |
| 168 | Phil Coke | SP | PIT | Willoughby Chubs |
| 169 | Brian Duensing | SP | CHC | puhd |
| 170 | Philip Humber | SP | false | Slackers |
Round 18
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 171 | Matt Harrison | SP | TEX | Pythagorean Triples |
| 172 | Kyle Farnsworth | RP | NYM | Jag Off Guards |
| 173 | Michael Bowden | RP | CHC | The 4 Aces |
| 174 | Josh Beckett | SP | LAD | Amalgamated Morons |
| 175 | Bruce Chen | SP | CLE | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 176 | Tim Collins | RP | COL | Turnbull AC's |
| 177 | Jeff Niemann | SP | TB | The Baseball Furies |
| 178 | Gavin Floyd | SP | TOR | Willoughby Chubs |
| 179 | Kevin Gregg | RP | CIN | puhd |
| 180 | Jim Johnson | RP | LAA | Slackers |
Round 19
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 181 | Jeremy Hellickson | SP | WSH | Pythagorean Triples |
| 182 | Doug Fister | SP | TEX | Jag Off Guards |
| 183 | John Danks | SP | CWS | The 4 Aces |
| 184 | Joaquín Benoit | RP | PIT | Amalgamated Morons |
| 185 | Freddy Garcia | SP | ATL | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 186 | Kyle Drabek | SP | AZ | Turnbull AC's |
| 187 | Alexi Ogando | SP | CLE | The Baseball Furies |
| 188 | John Lackey | SP | CHC | Willoughby Chubs |
| 189 | Luke Hochevar | SP | KC | puhd |
| 190 | Brandon League | RP | LAD | Slackers |
Round 20
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 191 | Derek Holland | SP | BOS | Pythagorean Triples |
| 192 | Dan Haren | SP | CHC | Jag Off Guards |
| 193 | Félix Hernández | SP | BAL | The 4 Aces |
| 194 | Joba Chamberlain | RP | CLE | Amalgamated Morons |
| 195 | Dustin McGowan | SP | MIA | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 196 | Neftali Feliz | SP | SEA | Turnbull AC's |
| 197 | Rick Porcello | SP | NYM | The Baseball Furies |
| 198 | Joe Nathan | RP | CHC | Willoughby Chubs |
| 199 | Ubaldo Jiménez | SP | COL | puhd |
| 200 | Daisuke Matsuzaka | SP | NYM | Slackers |
Round 21
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 201 | Jon Lester | SP | STL | Pythagorean Triples |
| 202 | Brian Matusz | SP | BAL | Jag Off Guards |
| 203 | Phil Hughes | SP | MIN | The 4 Aces |
| 204 | Alex Cobb | SP | DET | Amalgamated Morons |
| 205 | Andrew Miller | SP | STL | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 206 | Casey Janssen | RP | WSH | Turnbull AC's |
| 207 | David Robertson | RP | PHI | The Baseball Furies |
| 208 | Rafael Perez | RP | SEA | Willoughby Chubs |
| 209 | Carl Pavano | SP | MIN | puhd |
| 210 | David Pauley | RP | AZ | Slackers |
Round 22
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 211 | Francisco Liriano | SP | TOR | Pythagorean Triples |
| 212 | Brandon Morrow | SP | CHC | Jag Off Guards |
| 213 | Iván Nova | SP | PHI | The 4 Aces |
| 214 | Scott Downs | RP | KC | Amalgamated Morons |
| 215 | Bradley Penny | SP | MIA | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 216 | Justin Masterson | SP | BOS | Turnbull AC's |
| 217 | Chris Sale | SP | ATL | The Baseball Furies |
| 218 | Michael Pineda | SP | DET | Willoughby Chubs |
| 219 | Ricky Romero | SP | TOR | puhd |
| 220 | Chris Perez | RP | LAD | Slackers |
Round 23
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 221 | Darren Oliver | RP | TOR | Pythagorean Triples |
| 222 | Joakim Soria | RP | TOR | Jag Off Guards |
| 223 | Glen Perkins | RP | MIN | The 4 Aces |
| 224 | Greg Holland | RP | TEX | Amalgamated Morons |
| 225 | David Price | SP | LAD | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 226 | Joel Peralta | RP | CHC | Turnbull AC's |
| 227 | Max Scherzer | SP | TOR | The Baseball Furies |
| 228 | Fernando Rodney | RP | WSH | Willoughby Chubs |
| 229 | Jose Valverde | RP | NYM | puhd |
| 230 | James Shields | SP | CWS | Slackers |
Round 24
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 231 | Ervin Santana | SP | KC | Pythagorean Triples |
| 232 | Denard Span | OF | SEA | Jag Off Guards |
| 233 | Vinnie Pestano | RP | LAA | The 4 Aces |
| 234 | Colby Lewis | SP | TEX | Amalgamated Morons |
| 235 | Hisanori Takahashi | RP | CHC | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 236 | Unknown | — | — | Turnbull AC's |
| 237 | Koji Uehara | RP | CHC | The Baseball Furies |
| 238 | CC Sabathia | SP | NYY | Willoughby Chubs |
| 239 | Unknown | — | — | puhd |
| 240 | Joe Smith | RP | MIN | Slackers |
Round 25
| Pick | Player | Pos | MLB Team | Fantasy Team |
|---|
| 241 | Matt Moore | SP | BOS | Pythagorean Triples |
| 242 | Unknown | — | — | Jag Off Guards |
| 243 | Tony Sipp | RP | WSH | The 4 Aces |
| 244 | Jake Peavy | SP | SF | Amalgamated Morons |
| 245 | Matt Thornton | RP | SD | Sexual Tyrannosaurus |
| 246 | Unknown | — | — | Turnbull AC's |
| 247 | Jordan Walden | RP | STL | The Baseball Furies |
| 248 | Unknown | — | — | Willoughby Chubs |
| 249 | Unknown | — | — | puhd |
| 250 | Jason Vargas | SP | PHI | Slackers |